News Page

Main Content

A Lockout Hasn’t Started, but Baseball’s Trade Problems Have

Hunter Tierney 's profile
By Hunter Tierney
November 17, 2026
A Lockout Hasn’t Started, but Baseball’s Trade Problems Have

Trading for a starting pitcher usually comes with the same familiar questions: How’s his elbow? Can he handle another 180 innings? Was that second-half breakout real, or did he just get six starts against teams that couldn’t hit?

This winter, there’s another question to add to the list:

How much baseball are you actually getting?

That matters a lot when the other team wants your best prospects. Logan Gilbert might be exactly what your rotation needs. Steven Kwan might shore up your outfield defense and give your lineup someone who doesn’t treat every two-strike count like an invitation to swing harder. But if you’re trading for either player with only one season of control left, the uncertainty around 2027 has to be part of the conversation.

The selling team wants to be paid for a full season of a good player. The buyer can’t confidently assume they’ll get one.

And that can create a problem before anyone even picks up the phone.

The Phones Are Busy. Agreeing on Something Is Harder.

On Nov. 8th, MLB Network’s Jon Morosi reported that players with one year of control left — including Gilbert, Kwan, Joe Ryan and Sandy Alcantara — probably weren’t going to be moved for prospects anytime soon. With teams still unsure what the 2027 season will look like, giving up young players for a short-term piece felt like a tough sell. His sources said pending free agents could instead be traded for each other to “balance the risk.”

Morosi also reported that trade talks were further along than they normally would be this early. Teams are talking. They’re looking for ways to get better. The approaching shutdown is giving them a reason to move quickly.

It’s also giving them a reason to pump the brakes when someone asks for a top prospect.

At the GM meetings in Las Vegas, Boston’s Craig Breslow said “the cadence has been accelerated a bit,” while also noting that the big trades hadn’t come yet. Baltimore’s Mike Elias described his approach as a “normal November.”

Both things can be true. A front office can spend all day talking about a player and still have no idea what they're actually willing to give up.

You Don’t Get Your Prospects Back

The current collective bargaining agreement expires at 11:59 p.m. Eastern on Dec. 1st. Owners are widely expected to impose a lockout after that, which would put major-league trades and free-agent signings on hold. The expiration date is set. The length of the shutdown isn’t.

For a buyer, that creates a problem that goes well beyond the payroll department.

Say you’re willing to trade two good prospects for a pitcher because you’re expecting six months of starts and, if things go well, a few more in October. Now imagine a season that doesn’t start until June.

You might still want the pitcher. You might want him badly. But you’ve lost a big chunk of the production that made the original price make sense.

And no matter what happens with salary payments, those prospects are still gone.

The seller sees the same player differently. Their pitcher hasn’t suddenly lost his fastball because the labor talks are going badly. The club doesn’t want to take a smaller return for a problem they can’t fix from the baseball operations office.

So both teams can have a perfectly reasonable position, and still wind up with no deal.

There’s another complication: contract years and service time aren’t the same thing. Under the current agreement, a full service year generally requires 172 days. How a future settlement would handle a shortened or canceled season is still unknown. Clubs can’t simply assume they’d get an extra year of control to make up for the games they lost.

Three Names, Three Different Decisions

May 30, 2023; Miami, Florida, USA; Miami Marlins starting pitcher Sandy Alcantara (22) looks on against the San Diego Padres during the seventh inning at loanDepot Park.
Credit: Sam Navarro-Imagn Images

Gilbert makes the issue pretty easy to understand because Seattle has a legitimate baseball reason to consider moving a starter.

He finished 2026 with a 3.73 ERA and 205 strikeouts in 186 innings.

That’s a meaningful rotation upgrade for plenty of teams. He’s also entering his last season of club control, with MLB Trade Rumors projecting a $15.4 million arbitration salary.

Seattle's already said they're getting calls about their rotation. Adam Jude and Ryan Divish reported that the Mariners are looking for two hitters and bullpen help, with improving the defense also a priority. Moving pitching to address those needs is a real possibility.

That doesn’t mean Gilbert has to go, though. Seattle would be giving up something valuable, too. Having enough pitching to discuss a trade isn’t the same as having enough pitching to barely notice the guy leaving.

Kwan's a whole different version of the decision. He hit .282 with a .382 on-base percentage in 2026. He’s also eligible for free agency after the 2027 season.

A contender looking for a guy who gets on base and an established outfielder can see the appeal. Cleveland can also see what it would cost to take him out of their own lineup. If teams are discounting offers because of labor uncertainty, keeping him becomes easier to justify.

Then there’s Alcantara, who shouldn’t automatically be treated like somebody Miami's trying to unload.

The Marlins exercised his $21 million option after a season where he threw 214 innings with a 3.87 ERA.

The Rules Could Be Drastically Different Next April

The calendar is only part of what clubs are trying to price.

On Nov. 3rd, MLB proposed a $258.2 million salary cap and $180.2 million floor beginning in 2028, with the existing luxury-tax structure continuing in 2027. The union still completely opposes a cap of any kind.

A club can decide a player is worth his salary under today’s rules. What they can’t know is exactly how that commitment would fit into a financial system that hasn’t been negotiated yet.

Some proposals have also included earlier free agency for certain players 30 and older, with conditions attached. So when teams evaluate future control, they have to account for the possibility of changes without acting like those changes are already in place.

With another potential lockout looming, teams have to think about what happens if the 2027 season never gets played. The Yankees already accounted for that possibility in Cody Bellinger's contract. If baseball loses the entire 2027 season, his opt-out dates move back a year, ensuring New York gets at least two seasons of baseball from him before he can leave. But that protection isn't standard across MLB contracts. For teams considering trades, it's another complication they'll have to account for before giving up prospects or other assets.

That’s how real this has become. The concern has already made its way into contract language.

Waiting Has a Cost, Too

May 2, 2026; Bronx, New York, USA; New York Yankees left fielder Cody Bellinger (35) celebrates with teammates after hitting a solo home run against the Baltimore Orioles during the second inning at Yankee Stadium.
Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images

For contenders, the danger's pretty simple: an upgrade might be available in theory, but not at a price they can actually justify.

They can turn to free agency, where the cost is mostly money instead of a prospect package. They can look for someone with more team control. They can wait.

Of course, none of those options guarantees they’ll find an equally good player.

For sellers that actually want to move a pending free agent, the squeeze might be even tighter. Take a lesser offer now, or keep the player and hope the market makes more sense later. Waiting keeps open the possibility of a better deal, but only if the stars align.

A club that wants to keep their player can live with that. A club counting on a trade to restock their farm system has a much tougher call to make.

Players have the least control over any of this. Their names can bounce around for months while their teams wait for a better offer. If a shutdown stretches into the regular season, they’re looking at lost pay and lost playing time. For someone nearing free agency, losing the chance to put another strong season in front of bidders can affect a lot more than just one year.

Still, there’s a reason not to treat November hesitation as proof the whole winter's going to be dead.

The last lockout lasted 99 days, and baseball still played a full 162-game season in 2022.

The useful thing to watch now is what teams are actually willing to give up.

A rush of free-agent signings wouldn’t necessarily mean the prospect market for one-year players has thawed. Neither would a handful of trades involving established major leaguers.

All stats courtesy of MLB.com.


Looking for stories that inform and engage? From breaking headlines to fresh perspectives, WaveNewsToday has more to explore. Ride the wave of what’s next.

Latest News

Related Stories