News Page

Main Content

Defense, Damage & Decisions: A Brutal AFC Wild Card Weekend

Hunter Tierney 's profile
By Hunter Tierney
January 15, 2026
Defense, Damage & Decisions: A Brutal AFC Wild Card Weekend

If you were looking for clean football and stress-free wins, Wild Card weekend was the wrong place to start this year.

This round was about survival. About whether you can keep your footing when drives stall, when stars are limping, and when your quarterback is getting hit in ways that make you wince through the TV. It’s where teams either prove they can live in the ugly parts of the game… or spend the next eight months explaining why they couldn't.

Buffalo survived a fourth-quarter pinball machine in Jacksonville. New England dragged the Chargers into a three-hour defensive rock fight. And Houston? Houston walked into Pittsburgh and erased the Steelers’ offense.

None of these wins came easy. There were blown assignments, head-scratching calls, and moments where every fan base was convinced the football gods had picked a side. But that’s the point of Wild Card weekend.

Jaguars Had Their Chances, but Josh Allen Put the Team on His Back (Literally)

Bills 27, Jaguars 24

This one was chaos in the best and worst ways — the kind of game that never let you get comfortable, no matter which side you were on.

It wasn’t two offenses lighting it up and trading haymakers type of chaos. It was the grind-it-out, bodies-everywhere, how is this still happening kind of chaos. The fourth quarter alone had four lead changes, and once it got there, the game felt like it was rolling downhill with no brakes.

If you’re a Bills fan, those final 12 minutes probably took a couple years off your life. If you’re a Jaguars fan, that last drive felt like staring at your phone while it sits at one percent, begging it to hang on just a little longer.

Josh Allen Took the Hits and Kept Dragging Buffalo Forward

Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen (17) calls a play during the first quarter of an NFL football AFC Wild Card playoff matchup, Sunday, Jan. 11, 2026, in Jacksonville, Fla. The Bills defeated the Jaguars 27-24.
Credit: Corey Perrine/Florida Times-Union via Imagn Images

You can’t tell the story of this game without starting with how much Allen absorbed along the way.

He took a shot early that sent him into the medical tent for a head check. Later, he smashed his throwing hand into the helmet of his own right guard on a follow-through. Then, on a touchdown run, his left knee bent awkwardly underneath him, and he limped into the blue tent again.

Every time, it felt like this might be the moment Buffalo had to adjust the plan.

And every time, Allen came right back out and kept playing like nothing happened.

The stat line almost undersells how hard the night was:

  • 28-of-35 (80%) for 273 yards

  • 1 passing touchdown

  • 2 rushing touchdowns

  • And the one that mattered most: Buffalo’s first road playoff win in 33 years

What made it more impressive was that Jacksonville didn’t make it easy. The Jaguars pressured him. They hit him. They forced him to move. And instead of falling into the old trap — holding the ball too long or trying to play hero on every snap — Allen kept his composure.

The short game became his lifeline. Khalil Shakir was the steady presence underneath. Dalton Kincaid kept finding soft spots when Buffalo needed a conversion. It wasn’t flashy, but it was controlled, and it kept the Bills from spiraling.

Then, when the game demanded something bigger, Allen delivered it.

Late in the fourth quarter, with everything tight and the pressure cranked all the way up, he uncorked a 36-yard strike to Brandin Cooks, standing in against pressure with a defender closing fast. It was the kind of throw that doesn’t just move the ball — it shifts the mood.

The Tush Push Moment That Finally Made the Playoff Debate Feel Real

Let’s be honest: the whole “tush push” conversation usually makes people roll their eyes. It’s been argued to death, turned into rules debates, and beaten into the ground on every football show imaginable.

But Buffalo’s defining drive came down to a fourth-and-1 from the 11, in a game where every possession felt like the last slice of pizza on the table. Sean McDermott didn’t hesitate. The Bills lined up, called the push, and basically looked across the line at Jacksonville and said, “You know what this is. Stop it.”

And the Jaguars couldn’t.

O’Cyrus Torrence — who looks like he was built in a lab for moments like this — didn’t just give Allen a nudge. He wrapped him up, lifted him off the ground, and carried him forward like it was choreographed.

When Allen was ruled down at the one, there was no drama about what came next. Buffalo lined right back up and did it again, this time for the score, leaning fully into the idea that playoff football doesn’t always need to be clever — sometimes it just needs to be unapologetically physical.

This Was a Growing Moment for Jacksonville, and Those Hurt

Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Trevor Lawrence (16) looks to handoff during the fourth quarter of an NFL football AFC Wild Card playoff matchup, Sunday, Jan. 11, 2026, in Jacksonville, Fla. The Bills defeated the Jaguars 27-24.
Credit: Corey Perrine/Florida Times-Union via Imagn Images

Trevor Lawrence had his moments, but this was far from his best day:

  • 18-of-30, 207 yards

  • 3 touchdowns

  • 2 interceptions

Three touchdowns in a playoff game should be enough. Most nights, it is. But this wasn’t most nights, and those two picks — especially the last one — were the difference between Jacksonville pulling off a statement win and walking off the field stunned.

The Jaguars genuinely had Buffalo wobbling. They created chaos in the fourth quarter. For a stretch, it felt like one more clean drive might actually finish it. They got the ball back with a minute left after the back-to-back tush pushes, having one of the best kickers in the game ready to go if they could get him in range.

And then came the throw Lawrence wishes he could have back.

It wasn’t reckless. It wasn’t panic. It was the kind of decision young quarterbacks make when they’re trying to do just a tad too much. He tried to fit a ball into a tight window late, Tre’Davious White got a fingertip on it, and rookie safety Cole Bishop came down with it.

Lawrence now has seven turnovers in three playoff games, and while that number doesn’t tell the whole story, it does underline the uncomfortable truth Jacksonville is still learning: January doesn’t forgive small mistakes, especially late ones.

The Run Game Was There… But Calm Had to Come From the Quarterback

Jacksonville ran the ball well enough to make Buffalo uncomfortable. They had 118 yards on just 14 carries from their top two guys, and consistently put the offense in manageable situations. When Lawrence was playing free and confident, the passing game looked like it belonged on this stage.

But once the game sped up and every snap felt heavier — the margin for error disappeared.

That’s where the calm at quarterback becomes everything.

Lawrence didn’t play poorly overall, but in those final moments, the game needed restraint as much as aggression. The two interceptions flipped the game entirely, handing Josh Allen extra possessions in a game where Buffalo only needed one more opening.

Buffalo Escaped… But They’ve Got Stuff to Clean Up

Buffalo deserves real credit for winning a game that never fit their ideal script. This wasn’t a comfortable, front-running Bills win. It was messy. It was physical. And at times, it exposed parts of their defense they’ll need to tighten up quickly.

Then there’s the injury piece. The biggest one is Gabe Davis’ knee injury (torn ACL). That’s not just a depth-chart shuffle. It changes how defenses approach Buffalo. It puts more pressure on Khalil Shakir to be the consistent underneath option, on Dalton Kincaid to keep winning in space, and on Brandin Cooks to keep stretching the field.

The good news, of course, is obvious: Josh Allen is still Josh Allen. And Buffalo finally shook off a road playoff drought that had been hanging over the franchise for decades.

Now they head to Denver, where it’s going to be cold, loud, and that defense is going to be well-rested.

Patriots Flip the Script and Use Defense to Send Chargers Home

Oct 5, 2025; Orchard Park, New York, USA; New England Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel during the first half at Highmark Stadium.
Credit: Mark Konezny-Imagn Images

Patriots 16, Chargers 3

This game wasn’t close in the way the score suggests.

It was close on paper — 16-3 looks like one busted coverage or one broken tackle could’ve changed the entire thing. But if you actually watched it, you know that wasn't true. New England was in firm control of this game.

The Patriots didn’t dominate with fireworks. They dominated by dragging the game into the mud and daring the Chargers to function there. Every Los Angeles drive felt like work. Nothing came clean. Nothing was on schedule.

Justin Herbert spent the night holding the ball, double-clutching, and waiting for something to open up that never really did. The Patriots made him play in a phone booth and forced him to reset again and again.

The Vrabel Vibe Is Simple: “You’re Going to Bleed If You Want This”

The most on-brand moment of New England’s night didn’t come on a sack or a third-down stop. It came on the sideline.

Mike Vrabel left the game with a bloodied lip after an accidental head-butt during a celebration, which perfectly fit his image. It looked like something out of a bad football movie. And somehow, it also felt exactly right.

Vrabel didn’t come in promising shootouts or highlight reels. He showed up promising toughness and accountability. He’s been clear about it since Day 1: if you want to win in January, you’d better be willing to take hits, deliver hits, and keep playing when things get ugly.

This game was the cleanest version of that philosophy so far.

New England wasn’t overwhelming on offense. Drake Maye wasn’t carving anyone up like it was seven-on-seven. But the Patriots kept leaning on their defense, kept winning field position, and kept trusting that if they stuck to the plan, the Chargers would eventually crack.

They did.

A Defensive Masterclass

The Chargers finished with:

  • 207 total yards

  • 1-for-10 on third downs

  • 0 touchdowns

  • Six sacks allowed by their offensive line

That’s not just a bad playoff game. That’s a full system failure.

The Patriots earned every bit of that stat line, too. They made life miserable snap after snap, and they did it in a way that felt intentional, not chaotic.

New England constantly messed with the Chargers’ pre-snap reads. They showed pressure, bailed out. Showed zone, rotated late into man. Brought heat from weird angles, then dropped defenders right into Herbert’s check-down windows. Every time it looked like the Chargers might have something dialed up, the picture changed right as the ball was snapped.

That kind of defense doesn’t just beat you physically — it beats you mentally.

Patriots linebacker Bob Spillane summed it up perfectly afterward:

After the game, talking to a few of the guys on their team, they had no clue what we were doing. They came up and said that: ‘We had no clue what you guys were in all game.’

That’s the nightmare scenario for an offense in January, especially one that already struggles to stay on schedule.

By the fourth quarter, the confusion was obvious. Protection calls were late. Routes didn’t work against the coverages. And Herbert was left holding the ball, waiting for answers that never came.

Drake Maye Grew Up in Real Time — and That Was More Than Enough

Nov 13, 2025; Foxborough, Massachusetts, USA; New England Patriots quarterback Drake Maye (10) on the field against the New York Jets in the first quarter at Gillette Stadium.
Credit: David Butler II-Imagn Images

Drake Maye’s first half looked exactly like what it was: a quarterback feeling his way through his first playoff game.

He started 6-for-15 for 95 yards, took a couple sacks, and threw an interception — granted, it was tipped at the line, so it's not entirely on him, but it happened nonetheless. You could see him thinking instead of just reacting.

But the thing that mattered most is that it didn’t spiral.

Instead of forcing throws or speeding himself up, Maye settled in. He took what the Chargers gave him. He leaned on his legs when nothing was there. And slowly, you could see the game start to slow down for him.

The scramble before halftime — the 37-yarder that flipped field position and set up points — was the turning point. It wasn’t flashy, but it forced the Chargers to change how they defended him. Suddenly, they couldn’t just sit back and wait for mistakes. They had to account for Maye as a runner, and that opened things up.

Then came the throw everyone will remember: the touchdown to Hunter Henry. Clean pocket. Calm feet. Perfectplacement. It was the kind of throw that makes you stop talking about nerves and start talking about ceilings.

He didn’t carry the Patriots by himself, and he didn’t need to. He leaned on his defense, trusted his reads, and got help from young players making big-time plays — a fourth-and-4 conversion here, a tough catch there.

That’s how young quarterbacks survive January. Not by being perfect, but by figuring it out quickly enough to let the rest of the team win with them.

New England Looks Real. The Chargers Might Have to Rethink Some Things.

For New England, this win felt like validation.

A year ago, the Patriots were trying to figure out what they were. Now, they’ve won a playoff game behind a second-year QB, an aggressive defense, and a coach who looks like he was designed in a lab to win this style.

That’s a foundation.

For the Chargers, the offseason is going to be loud. Coaching changes. Scheme questions. Another year of “we have the quarterback, so why does it look like this?” conversations.

And it’s not just about Roman being gone. It’s about building an offense that actually matches Herbert’s talent instead of constantly forcing him into survival mode.

This Defense Just Might Carry This Team All the Way

Jan 12, 2026; Pittsburgh, PA, USA; Houston Texans quarterback C.J. Stroud (7) greets Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers following their AFC Wild Card Round game at Acrisure Stadium.
Credit: Barry Reeger-Imagn Images

Texans 30, Steelers 6

This game had a weird vibe early. At halftime, it was 7-6, and it honestly felt like one of those playoff games where Pittsburgh just hangs around forever. In the third quarter, it still felt like the Steelers were one decent drive away from flipping the whole thing.

And then Houston’s defense decided they had seen enough.

It didn’t unravel slowly. It didn’t turn on a bad bounce. It ended in a blink.

First, Will Anderson Jr. beat his man clean, strip-sacked Aaron Rodgers, and Sheldon Rankins scooped it up and rumbled 33 yards for a touchdown — completely sucking out whatever life was left in the stadium.

After the Steelers quickly stalled out on their next drive, Houston got the ball back and took six minutes off the clock with a touchdown drive that included a 33-yard pickup on third and four. Then, just to put the cherry on top, Calen Bullock jumped a throw, picked Rodgers off, and took it 50 yards the other way for a pick-six.

This game went from 7-6 to 30-6 in a span of ten and a half minutes. 

This wasn’t a shootout. It wasn’t even a back-and-forth. It was a slow squeeze, followed by a knockout.

And by the end, it didn’t feel like Houston stole one in Pittsburgh.

It felt like Houston announced something.

The Texans’ Defense Was Historic, and the Numbers Back It Up

We throw the word “historic” around a lot in January. Usually it’s shorthand for “that was really good.”

This time, it actually fits.

Houston held Pittsburgh to 175 total yards. The Steelers converted 2 of 14 third downs. They scored six points total — and three of those came off a possession that started in Houston’s lap.

Houston’s defense finished the night with a -33.4 EPA, the best mark by a playoff defense in the last decade.

Aaron Rodgers’ 14.3 QBR tells the same story. That’s not just a rough night — that’s a quarterback who never felt like he had answers.

The Texans didn’t just rush the passer and hope for mistakes. They rushed with discipline. They collapsed the pocket without losing contain. They forced Rodgers to move his feet, then took away the quick game that’s usually his escape hatch. And when he finally tried to force something late, Houston punished him for it.

That’s why Calen Bullock’s quote afterward landed the way it did.

Shoot, I think everybody knows we're the best defense. The whole world knows that. Every time we go out there we show it and we went out there and showed it today.

On the surface, it sounds bold. Almost cocky.

But then you remember what just happened.

The Texans walked into Pittsburgh — in January — and made a veteran quarterback look like he was playing underwater. They turned every Steelers possession into a grind, then slammed the door with two defensive touchdowns.

At that point, it's not trash talk.

It's a receipt.

When C.J. Stroud Didn’t Have It, the Texans Picked Him Up Anyway

Dec 21, 2025; Houston, Texas, USA; Houston Texans quarterback C.J. Stroud (7) signals to an official during the second half against the Las Vegas Raiders at NRG Stadium.
Credit: Troy Taormina-Imagn Images

Here’s the part that should make the rest of the AFC a little uneasy.

C.J. Stroud had a rough night. A rough night.

He fumbled five times, lost two of them, and threw a brutal red-zone interception that felt like it should have been the exact moment Pittsburgh flipped the game on its head. For long stretches, it looked like the Texans were begging the Steelers to take control.

And somehow, Houston still walked out of there with a 24-point win.

That’s the story. When your quarterback is coughing the ball up like it’s a hot potato, and the other team still can’t make you pay for it, you’re not just winning — you’re playing a different brand of football.

To Stroud’s credit, this never turned into a snowball. He didn’t hang his head. He didn’t start forcing throws to make up for mistakes.

And when Stroud needed a lifeline, he had one.

Christian Kirk.

With Nico Collins out after a concussion, Kirk became the emergency exit. He finished with 144 yards and a touchdown, consistently bailing Houston when the offense desperately needed something to work.

The run game helped settle things too. Woody Marks ripped off tough, no-nonsense runs, and Houston leaned into the ground game late to keep the clock running.

Stroud wasn’t the hero of this game. But he didn’t lose it either — and that might have been the most important thing he did.

Houston Just Announced Themselves

The Texans defense is a weapon — the kind that travels, the kind that shortens games, and the kind that doesn’t care whose stadium it’s in.

And in January, a weapon like that changes everything.

Now they head to New England for a matchup that feels less like a chess match and more like a street fight. Two teams that love defense. Two teams that lean into physicality. Two teams that would be perfectly content winning a game 17-13 if it means moving on.

Next Week Won’t Be Pretty — And the AFC Wouldn’t Have It Any Other Way

Oct 19, 2025; Denver, Colorado, USA; Fans celebrate the Denver Broncos win against the New York Giants at Empower Field at Mile High.
Credit: Isaiah J. Downing-Imagn Images

Bills at Broncos feels like a real test of how much Buffalo has left in the tank after surviving a war in Jacksonville. It’s not just about Josh Allen making ridiculous throws late — it’s about whether the Bills can hold up physically, snap after snap, against a No. 1 seed that’s built to punish mistakes.

Denver doesn’t need Allen to implode; it just needs him to be slightly off once or twice, because that defense feasts on freelancing quarterbacks. This one feels like it’s going to be uncomfortable deep into the fourth quarter.

Texans at Patriots feels less like a chess match and more like a bar fight that spills out into the parking lot. Two defenses that love disguises. Two coaching staffs perfectly fine winning ugly.

If Stroud protects the ball and Houston hits one explosive play, that defense is good enough to carry them anywhere. If Drake Maye keeps using his legs as an escape hatch and New England keeps turning third downs into puzzles, the Patriots can absolutely earn a spot in the AFC Championship Game.

All stats courtesy of NFL Pro.

Looking for stories that inform and engage? From breaking headlines to fresh perspectives, WaveNewsToday has more to explore. Ride the wave of what’s next.

Latest Sports

Related Stories