The Mets weren't supposed to be a slow-burn team or one you check back on in June. This was a plug-it-in-and-watch-it-work roster. Juan Soto anchoring it. Francisco Lindor setting the tone. Bo Bichette and Marcus Semien rounding it out. Luis Robert Jr. for juice. Alvarez, Vientos, enough depth and enough arms behind it to feel like the whole thing should hold up over 162.

On paper, it looked like one of those teams that doesn’t need everything to go right — just enough.

If only games were played "on paper".

Through early May, the Mets are 12-22, sitting dead last in the NL East with the worst record in baseball and already 12.5 games behind the Braves for first place. They’ve been outscored 149-118. They ripped off a 12-game losing streak. This is a team that was given an 80% chance to make the playoffs before the season started. Now they're closer to 25%. 

A bad start is one thing. This is something else.

The Payroll Makes This Impossible To Shrug Off

The thing about the Mets is nobody backed them into this corner. They chose it. That’s been the whole point of the Steve Cohen era — if there’s a problem, you don’t live with it, you outspend it. Wrong fit? Fix it with another move. Thin depth? Add more pieces. Need a bat? Go get one. It’s not subtle, and it’s not supposed to be. That’s the advantage.

And honestly, for a while, it’s been kind of refreshing. Fans don’t have to talk themselves into half-measures or pretend a bargain signing is secretly a difference-maker. The Mets can go get the actual difference-maker.

Right now, they’re sitting on a $368 million payroll, with the luxury tax pushing the real cost to nearly half a billion dollars… and they look like a team trying to scrape together two or three runs a night. Spending big doesn't automatically guarantee a World Series — baseball’s never that simple — but spending this much is supposed to at least raise the floor.

The Mets’ floor hasn’t been raised. It’s collapsed.

They kicked the year off looking like they might’ve finally figured it out for once, then dropped a 12-game losing streak that felt like it lasted a month. Longest skid since 2004. Swept left and right, offense going completely silent for stretches, bullpen leaking runs, and even the shiny new additions looking lost at the plate. Soto missed some early time with that calf thing, sure, but even when he’s been out there this lineup has been anemic — near the bottom of the league in runs, OPS, you name it. It’s not just one guy. The whole operation is sputtering.

When a small-market team gets off to a start like this, the conversation’s usually about development, injuries, patience, and the future. When a team spends like the Mets — the second-highest payroll in baseball again, by the way — they get a much shorter leash. You don’t pour this much money into a roster so fans can squint at expected stats and convince themselves things are secretly fine.

So no, this isn’t people piling on just because it’s the Mets. This is what happens when expectations are this high, and the results fall this flat.

The Offense Has Been the Biggest Crime Scene

The easiest way to explain the Mets’ mess is also the most damning: they simply cannot score.

Not “they’ve been a little unlucky.” Not “they’re leaving some meat on the bone.” They've been one of the worst offensive teams in baseball, full stop. Through 34 games they were hitting .227 with a .290 on-base percentage, a .343 slugging, and a pathetic .633 OPS. Averaging just 3.5 runs a night. Those are the stats you see from a rebuilding team begging fans for patience while the prospects cook — not a franchise whose payroll could pay for the Guardians, Marlins, and Rays rosters, and still have $100 million left over for a yacht.

And it’s not like one bad week dragged everything down. They went through an eight-game stretch in April where they scored a grand total of 12 runs and got shut out three separate times. At some point, it stopped feeling like a slump and started feeling like a full-blown identity crisis.

That’s the most frustrating part. The pitching hasn’t been perfect, but it’s been playable enough. The Mets aren’t 12-22 because every single night turned into a home-run derby for the other guys. They’re 12-22 because the lineup has gone dead quiet so often that pitchers feel like they have to be perfect just to steal a win.

When you build a roster around expensive veterans and star-level bats, the offense is supposed to be the safe part. It’s supposed to be the engine that keeps you afloat while the rotation figures itself out.

MLB’s own Statcast data just rubs more salt in the wound. The Mets have been absolute garbage against fastballs — a .640 OPS against them (four-seamers, two-seamers, cutters), dead last in the majors. They rank 29th in expected slugging on four-seamers specifically, and 29th again on anything 95 mph and up. That’s a brutal problem in today’s game. If you can’t punish velocity, pitchers don’t have to get cute. They can just come right at you.

The Mets Blew It Up… For This?

After that 83-79 disappointment last year, they let Pete Alonso and Edwin Díaz walk in free agency. Traded away Brandon Nimmo and Jeff McNeil. Then they went shopping: signed Bo Bichette, Jorge Polanco, and Devin Williams, and traded for Marcus Semien, Luis Robert Jr., and Freddy Peralta. Those aren't small tweaks.

It feels like buying a brand-new sports car that looks incredible in the driveway… and then stalls at every red light.

Bichette’s been bounced around the infield and hasn’t hit nearly enough — sitting at .243 with a brutal .601 OPS through 34 games. Semien, at 35, was supposed to be the steady veteran anchor at second, and he’s hitting .213 with a .544 OPS. Polanco was brought in to mash in the middle of the order and he’s already banged up on the IL. Robert, the guy with all the impressive tools but a rap sheet of injuries, is back on the shelf with a lumbar disc issue. Even Peralta and Williams haven’t exactly lit the world on fire yet.

They shipped out productive pieces they knew well and brought in bigger names with bigger price tags, and so far the early return has been an utter disaster.

Look, it doesn’t mean every move was doomed. Bichette’s got a real track record when he’s right. Semien’s been an excellent player for years. Robert’s upside is stupid when he’s healthy. Peralta can absolutely help a rotation, and Devin Williams has been one of the nastiest relievers in baseball when he’s locked in.

But roster construction isn’t about collecting resumes. It’s about fit, depth, roles, and what happens when Plan A gets punched square in the mouth.

Injuries Matter, But They Don't Explain Everything

To be fair, the Mets haven’t exactly caught any breaks. Soto missed time early. Lindor’s been out. Robert is on the injured list. Mauricio fractured his thumb. Senga’s been sidelined. Polanco hasn’t stayed on the field consistently either. That’s real, and pretending it doesn’t matter would be lazy.

But injuries explain some of this. They don’t explain all of it.

Every team deals with guys going down. That’s just part of a 162-game season. The difference is that the Mets built this roster to be able to deal with that better than most. That’s the whole point of having this kind of payroll.

Soto, for what it’s worth, has been exactly what he’s supposed to be when he’s out there. That’s not the issue. The issue is that too much of the lineup around him has either underperformed or been unavailable.

And that’s how you end up here.

Mendoza's Under Pressure, But This Is Bigger Than the Manager

Carlos Mendoza is the easiest target in the world right now because that’s just how it works in baseball. Team loses 12 straight and looks completely lifeless at the plate? Every little move you make gets second-guessed.

The Mets have publicly backed him, and honestly? That’s not crazy. This doesn’t look like a simple “fire the manager” situation. No skipper is waving some magic wand and magically turning a .633 OPS into a scary offense overnight. Mendoza isn’t the one whiffing on fastballs. He didn’t build this expensive, high-maintenance roster with all the moving parts. He wasn’t the one who decided which veterans to bet big on and which longtime fan favorites to ship out.

But he’s also not invisible in this.

Managers set the tone. They feel when a team is tightening up. They decide how long you ride struggling bats, how aggressive you get when things aren’t clicking, how much urgency shows up on a random Tuesday in May. And right now, the Mets don’t look loose. They don’t look confident. They look like a team waiting for something to go wrong — and usually getting exactly that.

Still, if the Mets are gonna fix this, it can’t just be about swapping out the guy who has to stand at the podium after another loss. This has to be about the whole operation — from the front office down.

The Mets Are Already Running Out of Cushion

And that’s where this gets uncomfortable.

Because yes, it’s early May. And yes, baseball is weird. Teams flip a switch all the time. A couple good weeks can make a bad start feel like a distant memory. Lindor coming back helps. A few bats heating up changes the entire tone of this team. We’ve all seen seasons turn faster than they should.

But you don’t get to dig a hole like this and pay your way out of it. It's too late for that

They didn’t just start slow. They handed over a huge chunk of the season already. To get to 80 wins from 12-22, they’d have to play like one of the best teams in baseball the rest of the way. Maybe they’re capable of it. Maybe the offense finds their footing.

Could they? Maybe. The talent is still there. You can still talk yourself into this team looking completely different by July.

But listen to how that sounds.

That’s a lot of “maybe” for a team that was built specifically to avoid needing that many things to break right.

The Mets spent like a club trying to erase all doubt, and instead they just created more of it. They’ve got the payroll of a powerhouse, the expectations of a legit contender, and so far the production of a team that would be lucky to get called mediocre.

All stats courtesy of MLB.com.

Looking for stories that inform and engage? From breaking headlines to fresh perspectives, WaveNewsToday has more to explore.